I am sure I am going against the grain here, but I am a bit of a BH lover myself. I purchased and financed a BH92 at 0% when I picked up the MX…what a deal to get that on a dollar that is dropping like a rock. That’s the whole reason I bought the MX actually…id do it again too.
Now to the BH, Do I need it? No. Would it be dollar wise to rent? Most likely yes in a single transaction…but once I ask that question most uses cases for most of my implements and tractor also go out the window….i am not in production so I suspect in most cases for most things rent might be dollar wise. I don’t use most implements most days, I don’t use most of my wrenches or my cordless drills, washer/dryer (and I am not about to go to laundry mat…if she can’t afford a washer or dryer she can’t afford me or my hobbies) most days either…same for the guns before they were lost in the boating accident….i am not about to rent my tools and implements or toys that I have intention to use more than once. Do I care? Absolutely not, and here’s why…absolute accessibility, pride of ownership and it’s fun (it’s a lot fun actually…like playing in the sandbox) I am spread between a full time job and 3 properties 4 hours apart. I have a tough time planning work for weather much less machine availability. My time is worth something even if not in a price comparison (reasonable quantified).
the only thing I would have done different is I would rather have the BH for the B because most of my uses would be on smaller jobs. Then rent a large task specific machine as others have said for larger scopes of work which would be much more infrequent.
At the end of the day I suspect I’ll keep and maintain and enjoy a BH while I have a tractor and mid size properties. At some point I could see selling the BH92 if I were picking up a B size TLB. For now the 92 stays (but I’d rather have the BH on the B for my uses)
But everyone has different use case and rational. YMMV.