hunterguy, I'm in a similar spot to you i.e. trying to make the best decision. I've been cutting 5 or so acres for the past 5 years using the BX with a 54" mid-mount mower and there are so many holes and ruts in the field that both the BX and I get beaten up and it's not a whole lot of fun to be honest. I don't cut the grass as much as I should because it's a real chore to do it. It not the time it takes as much as the discomfort. I should be cutting more than 5 acres, closer to 15 acres really, but there's no way I'm doing that with the BX.
I was picking up parts this past Saturday and the manager at the local Kubota dealership told me that I'd be much better off using the MX with a rotary cutter for the 5 acres and suggested the RCR1272 of which they have 12 in stock, and it's their most popular model by far. Obviously the dealer would rather move the inventory they have so they're pushing me in that direction. The MX is way softer riding than the BX and 72" beats 54", not to mention the ground speed of the MX compared to the BX. This got me looking at rotary cutters and comparing the RCR1272 to the RCR1872 and RCR2072. The dealer has a 2072 in stock but it's $4,400 so not really my first choice. The 1272 is $1,981 and the 1872 is $2,916. I would rather buy once and cry once and with the heavier duty gearbox the 1872 makes the most sense to me. I don't plan on cutting any saplings since I don't have any. It's mostly grass with some knapweed and gorse thrown in.
With a good rotary mower behind the MX I think I'll be able to regularly cut a lot more acreage. I've asked the dealer to look into the availability of an 1872. I was thinking about selling the 54" mid-mount mower deck but realized that I can use the BX on many of the smoother sections around the house that I'm currently mowing with a Honda walk behind.
Decisions, decisions.