You know, the reality is that horsepower is horsepower no matter the color. They all have their quirks and issues as evidenced on this forum.
Eric, what ever you find that will do the job for the right price... go for it! I was a pretty diehard red guy growing up, still am, would love to have a nice 55-60 HP IH of some sort. But I couldn't pass up the price I paid for my M4500 (a net price of about $1,700), and even though it is orange it does the job for me.
Ford has made some pretty dependable stuff over the years and dealers (New Holland) still service all the older tractors. Be hard to go wrong with a bigger tractor, even if just slightly so. I don't have 4-wd either, a few times that it would be nice, but for a tractor that mostly makes hay I'm glad more often than not that I don't have to bother with the extra maint and tire cost.
Budget has always been my obstacle too.