Really all depends on what you need to do with it and what works out better in the long run. I have both a grading box and a blade. Each one had its own abilitys and both do every different things. A grading box is handy for moving bulk material fast and the ability to take the teeth and rip up the ground is a bonus as well. I have a blade as whell but I mainly keep that just for moving snow in the winter time. I have on a rare ocassion used the blade to move dirt but its just not as usefull as the grading box.