Tireguy, funny you came along and posted this because a few days ago I posted this on another forum.
I finally got a little free time so I decided to go through the trouble of measuring the ACTUAL rolling circumference of the Carlisle All Trail vs the Firestone Turf & Field. Luckily, I mount my own tires using a manual tire changer so I was able to do this experiment at no cost other than a sore back (hey, I'm 54 years old, cut me some slack) and some time.
First I checked the air pressure in the Carlisle I had already mounted. 28 psi is where I run these tires on the tractor. Used a level to put a mark at the top and bottom of the tire (vertically level) then a mark on the concrete at the bottom of the level. Rolled the tractor forward till the marks went one full revolution and came to vertically level again, then put a mark on the concrete. Measured the distance between marks (which is of course the rolling circumference). The Carlisle have a loaded (please note I have a FEL installed) rolling circumference of 60 inches.
I removed one of the wheels, dis-mounted the Carlisle, mounted the old OEM Firestone I had recently taken off. Put the wheel back on the tractor with 25 psi in the tire. Used the level to duplicate the way I made the marks again. Measured between the marks and found out the Firestones have a loaded rolling circumference of 62 inches.
Now I'm a little surprised at the Firestones because the Firestone website specifies a rolling circumference of 61 inches. This means we can't even go by the info provided by the tire manufacturer.
Now I have to eat my words because I decided that was too much difference. I took the other Carlisle off and I'm back to running the dry rotted Firestones for now. Looks like I may be back to square one of getting all four wheels and tires replaced with R1s. This doesn't really bother me too much because I could use the extra traction anyway. But for those of you that need turfs, I can't recommend the Carlisle All Trail like I originally thought (unless you never use 4X4).