To fill or not to fill...also, spacers

GrizBota

Well-known member

Equipment
L3830HST/LA724, B2601/LA435/RCK54-32, RCR1872, CDI 66”grapple, pallet forks
Apr 26, 2023
1,153
736
113
Oregon
You sure are an angry little Elf Mr. Griz.... I'll state my assumptions and what I believe to be actuality. You can try to pick this apart if you want... What I will explain is static conditions.

First, never presume or assume... it gets you in trouble when trying to determine a real life condition. Why would you presume the center of mass is at the mid point of the tractor rear axle? Is it really? always? It's not, there are many things that determine the center of mass, it is not always at a mid point, it can be, but often is is not, or it can be changed. Changes in material density, distance from pivot point (yes.... that useless lever arm again) all potentially change the center of mass. By displacing the forces along the base (or axle) furthest from the tipping point, it will locate the center of mass in lateral axis further away from the midpoint of the axle. This can be calculated by the use of forces/moments and of course, that pesty little lever arm. Now... we just added weight (as to how it affects the overall moment) to the non pivot side of the tractor by separating that heavy weighted tire as it's own entity. Now, the center of mass just moved away from the tipping point.... now go back to your free body diagram... do your stick figures and notice how much more of an angle is now required to get the center of mass over the tipping point (which would be opposite/low side tire). When this tipping point is established, it has a zero lever arm 0x0=0, where all of the other forces against it, including the opposite tire at the extended 4", which calculates 70"x400lbs(?)... quite a force. See how that center of mass has moved? Therefore increasing the degree of slop required to reach the tipping point.

Let me ask you something.... when you look at your tractor from the side, where is the center of mass? Now, add the bucket and a scoop of gravel, did the center of mass change? (hint: it did) (the tractor is in a static position, just a different condition, just so we're on the same page). Now.... your a tractor guy and you don't like the calculations anymore of your presumed center of gravity vs. your now real life condition... it doesn't feel safe does it?.... what do you do?? holy smokes... we should add more weight to the opposite side of that pivot point (front tires) (the one you say doesn't matter).... maybe a ballast box, loaded tires, an implement? I don't know, maybe some farmer will figure out a way to offset that pivot point by adding a moment in the opposite direction of the loader?? That Damn Lever Arm agian! Bastard! Hum...interesting concept. it seems when considering tipping points in length direction of the tractor, with the addition of ballast we were able to adjust the moment by moving weight (counter weight) away from the pivot point .... frickn lever arm again, uff.... anyway, I'm sure you get the concept.

No... the free body diagram doesn't trump actual physics. That was the starter kit. I will give it to you.... without the consideration of reality, your math was correct. But, your math does not take into account the potential displacement of loads and their affect on the reactions they generate. These loads I say are displaced are still considered static. The more weight to the outside, the more stable the condition. If you were analyzing a solid brick.... I'd give you an A+

Ever wonder why the leaning tower of Pisa hasn't yet fallen over? it's because they continue adding weights, opposite the side it's leaning.... short lever arm ... dam it, again... so lots of weights. Anyway.... they continue to shift the center of mass by adding these weights. So, if and when they cannot counter balance the continued leaning the center of mass will drift past the pivot point.... this temporary fix won't last that much longer unfortunately.

We'll just agree to disagree on this one. you are right ... I needed to get my statistics "in order"... Have a Merry Christmas... honestly.
Thanks for the cute rant Charlie. Throw a fit and fall in it seems to be the applicable analogy. That seems to be the human condition go to when folks realize they are struggling to defend a baseless opinion. Clearly you have no background to defend your opinion analytically. If you want to correct the math, do it. Ranting won’t change that math.

I hold no umbrage here. I do encourage you to have a well thought out case and presentation before correcting someone’s math based on your opinion (those are sort of like the assumptions you mentioned).

Merry Christmas to you too.
 

OntheRidge

Well-known member
Lifetime Member

Equipment
Kubota L47 TLB, Homestead 55" grapple, LP 1684 rear blade, WR Long 84" snowplow
Nov 1, 2020
328
382
63
25427
Well, this thread went downhill. Almost sorry I started it.:rolleyes: Why do so many of these turn into a testosterone battle? :unsure:
 

The_Wingnut

Member
Lifetime Member

Equipment
Grand L4060, ZD21, ZD28, ZD331, RTV X1100C, Branson 3820, JD 1020, JD 50
Dec 8, 2021
91
63
18
61
Tyner, NC
Well, this thread went downhill. Almost sorry I started it.:rolleyes: Why do so many of these turn into a testosterone battle? :unsure:
It was a good and informative thread for a nut like me....
I've learned over the years, most people's line of thought is correct and some can articulate their thoughts better than others. That's why I don't chime in too many times, maybe just to ask a question, I find it difficult to convey my thoughts and/or opinion so I just read and learn. I find value in all expressed opinions even if the opinion seems off base it may just change my optic and I will find value in that.

I said all of that just to say keep creating the threads...never know when one will help someone like me!

MERRY CHRISTMAS to all!
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 users

Henro

Well-known member

Equipment
B2910, BX2200, KX41-2V mini Ex., Beer fridge
May 24, 2019
5,782
2,968
113
North of Pittsburgh PA
It was a good and informative thread for a nut like me....
I've learned over the years, most people's line of thought is correct and some can articulate their thoughts better than others. That's why I don't chime in too many times, maybe just to ask a question, I find it difficult to convey my thoughts and/or opinion so I just read and learn. I find value in all expressed opinions even if the opinion seems off base it may just change my optic and I will find value in that.

I said all of that just to say keep creating the threads...never know when one will help someone like me!

MERRY CHRISTMAS to all!
I agree. Even the disputes that come up have some value. IF we look beyond the words and try to see what each person is trying to express.

Best wishes for the Holiday Season, and as Wingnut says: Merry Christmas to ALL...
 

fried1765

Well-known member

Equipment
Kubota L48 TLB, Ford 1920 FEL, Ford 8N, SCAG Liberty Z, Gravely Pro.
Nov 14, 2019
7,843
5,066
113
Eastham, Ma
I agree. Even the disputes that come up have some value. IF we look beyond the words and try to see what each person is trying to express.

Best wishes for the Holiday Season, and as Wingnut says: Merry Christmas to ALL...
Has this all now really become just: "go along, to get along"?
Merry Christmas!
 

Tim Horton

Active member
Mar 22, 2018
260
45
28
Lake Superior
YES.... ALWAYS fill rear tires... Product used depends on your local weather and budget.. I did a DIY fill on one tractor using auto antifreeze and -35F washer fluid mix.. There are heavier products by the gallon, but this was the most budget friendly mix available at the time.. It worked well..