New L4600 vs used MX5100

rkwilli96

New member
Sep 5, 2012
2
0
0
minerva, ohio
I can get a new L4600 with loader for $2300 less than a well equipped use MX5100. 5100 has double rear hydraulics, canopy, heavy duty bucket with cutting blade.

Problem is I know that the 5100 was run pretty hard during its short life, 140 hrs. He ran a 4 bottom 16" plow, handled round bales, buried it in the mud several times, ocasionally ran Kerosene through it and at least once crossed a deep crek that put the exhaust underwater.

Should I be afraid of the used machine because I know it was run hard?

What implements require the rear hydraulics?

The loader on 4600 is lighter duty, my primary uses will be small cattle operation, clearing some land, landscaping, general farm chores.

I have a JCB backhoe for heavy duty requirements
 

Eric McCarthy

New member
Lifetime Member

Equipment
Kubota B6100E
Dec 21, 2009
5,223
7
0
43
Richmond Va
My advise is save the extra 2300 bucks and buy the tractor you know hasn't been ran threw the ringer. You cant go wrong with that new tractor smell!
 

hodge

Well-known member
Lifetime Member

Equipment
John Deere 790 John Deere 310 backhoe Bobcat 743
Nov 19, 2010
2,906
453
83
Love, VA
My advise is save the extra 2300 bucks and buy the tractor you know hasn't been ran threw the ringer. You cant go wrong with that new tractor smell!
I agree with Eric. And, especially if you have a backhoe for heavy duties, you don't really need the MX. Buy a new tractor with confidence and a warranty, and stay clear of a well abused tractor.
Welcome to OTT! Don't be a stranger!
 

rkwilli96

New member
Sep 5, 2012
2
0
0
minerva, ohio
Thanks for the quick input, I keep flipping, but my gut says go with the new. While I test rode and inspected the 5100 the gent had several beers and opened up about how tough the machine was, began describine the above mentioned uses. I don't know if there was any break in.

After seeing Erics double bale load I have confidence that the 4600 will handle what I need! Also there was a 4310 with grapple pics showing capability greater than I expected.