BH Bucket Size

93543

New member

Equipment
future bx23s
Jan 6, 2021
6
0
1
So. Cal
Hey All new guy here - Pick.
Before we go there, lol - I am the home owner the BX23S is marketed & made for - 1 acre tract house in the boonies, tired of 20 years of shovel, rake, wheelbarrow work. I expect to scratch out the check in Feb/March.

My question is this - does soil type come in to play when deciding on bucket size? I was going to get the 16" figuring easier to back fill a hole too large than make a small hole bigger - useage will be trenching for grey water line, digging tree holes and removing smaller stumps. Soil where trenching and planting holes is hard, sandy rock filled desert, for the most part.

So, the 16" or the 12" - will the 12" be better in my soil type?

Thanks in advance - love this forum, been lurking for awhile 😂.

Pick
 

torch

Well-known member

Equipment
B7100HSD, B2789, B2550, B4672, 48" cultivator, homemade FEL and Cab
Jun 10, 2016
2,617
864
113
Muskoka, Ont.
Small buckets require less force in hard soil but may not empty sticky soils (eg: damp clay).

So my guess would be 12" for hard, sandy desert soil. But someone with real experience will undoubtedly be along shortly.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user

UpNorthMI

Well-known member
Lifetime Member

Equipment
L3200, L3901, MX5800, SVL75-2, KX040
May 12, 2020
850
568
93
Up North, MI
I’d go the 12” bucket route based on your ground. if you plan a lot of stomp removal, a ripper or rake attachment are very useful.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user

pokey1416

Well-known member
Lifetime Member

Equipment
Grand L4060HSTC, BH92 Backhoe, HLA Snow Pusher, Dirt Dog Tiller, EA DiscHarrow
Jun 24, 2020
556
825
93
SW Michigan
I don’t know the capacity of your machine I like my 18” I would think 16” would be easier to get soil to dump. Whichever you choose make sure it has teeth. You’ll get your greatest breakout force with bucket curl. Consider the manual thumb option it’s a real lifesaver.
 

Lil Foot

Well-known member
Lifetime Member

Equipment
1979 B7100DT Gear, Nissan Hanix N150-2 Excavator
May 19, 2011
7,515
2,543
113
Peoria, AZ
My place in the mountains has tons of interlocked rocks & very hard soil. My B670 hoe is not very strong compared to modern equipment, so the narrowest bucket (10") is basically required. After the initial dig, I can usually re-dig with my bigger bucket. (16")
The 16" bucket works for sediment & gravel washed into my water course, or in the desert where I live. (Phoenix area)
As stated above, stumps, rocks, & such are easier with a narrower bucket, more material moved per scoop with larger buckets.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user

Henro

Well-known member

Equipment
B2910, BX2200, KX41-2V mini Ex., Beer fridge
May 24, 2019
5,781
2,965
113
North of Pittsburgh PA
With our clay a wider bucket is better. For your soil type either should work fine.

BUT extra width of a trench can be desirable sometimes. I rarely use the 10 inch bucket I have, and keep the 16” on all the time. Our soil makes the 10” a nightmare to use if at all damp. Bucket sticks half full most of the time.

My son in law bought the 16” when he got his new BX23S last summer. No complaints so far.

In your case it sounds like either will work fine, although the 12” might be better if the ground is extremely hard. I say might, because I don’t know...in theory it would be.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user

dirtydeed

Well-known member
Lifetime Member

Equipment
B2650 BH77, U27-4R2, BX23TLBM, box blade, rear blade, flail mower, Stump Grinder
Dec 8, 2017
3,019
3,672
113
Wind Gap, PA
I didn't think a 16" bucket was even an option for the hoe on a BX23S.

I had a BX23 years ago...you wont want anything larger than a 12" bucket.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user

93543

New member

Equipment
future bx23s
Jan 6, 2021
6
0
1
So. Cal
I don’t know the capacity of your machine I like my 18” I would think 16” would be easier to get soil to dump. Whichever you choose make sure it has teeth. You’ll get your greatest breakout force with bucket curl. Consider the manual thumb option it’s a real lifesaver.
The 23 is the baby, enough power to do the landscaping - shovel free, LOL! Yes, the thumb will be on it - thanks for the input!
 

93543

New member

Equipment
future bx23s
Jan 6, 2021
6
0
1
So. Cal
I didn't think a 16" bucket was even an option for the hoe on a BX23S.

I had a BX23 years ago...you wont want anything larger than a 12" bucket.
Perfect - thank you!! I'm comfortable now with putting the 12" on it after all of the input - it's why I asked!!