Loader bucket or snow pusher

DustyRusty

Well-known member

Equipment
2020 BX23S, BX2822 Snowblower, Curtis Deluxe Cab,
Nov 8, 2015
6,237
4,816
113
North East CT
I guess that the blade isn't going to work very well. Your tractor doesn't have enough weight and pushing power to move heavy snow. I remember a few years ago when I tried to blade through the snow with my BX23S with a blade on the front. It didn't work out very well when the snow stopped the tractor and the tractor went off the edge of the driveway. I put the snowblower on and blew the snow into the field. Once I had the heavy snow gone, I could use the plow to clean the pavement. My tractor has Rim Guard in the rear tires and over 600# in the weight box in the rear of the tractor with turf tires. This year I am going to try R4 tires to see if they work better in the heavy wet snow that we traditionally get.
 

Bearcatrp

Well-known member

Equipment
BX1880 with loader, mower and 3 point
Mar 28, 2023
645
343
63
Minnesota
My other option is to raise the front blade to about 3 inches off the ground to move some of the snow and the 3 point blade remove the rest. Guess I will find out this winter.
 

Moose7060

Well-known member

Equipment
M7060, L3902 HST, Farm King PT740, HLA 2500 Snowpusher, LandPride RCR1872
Oct 14, 2023
530
1,195
93
bc
My other option is to raise the front blade to about 3 inches off the ground to move some of the snow and the 3 point blade remove the rest. Guess I will find out this winter.
The best thing about trial and error is you find out what works best for you!
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user

Bearcatrp

Well-known member

Equipment
BX1880 with loader, mower and 3 point
Mar 28, 2023
645
343
63
Minnesota
The best thing about trial and error is you find out what works best for you!
This will be more trial and error. The 3 point with the 6 foot blade has been working great. Had the bucket on to scrape away from garage and push snow beyond the edge. This should work on 5 inches or less. If I get bogged down, lift the front blade a few inches to move the majority of the snow and let the rear blade do the rest. Nice thing about the front blade is I can change the pitch with the loader. If we do get real heavy snow, the bucket will go back on. Winter is anyone’s guess. Everyone states different amount of snow. If it doesn't work out, can use it to level off gravel instead of using the bucket and scratching the crap out of the bottom.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user

ajschnitzelbank

Well-known member
Lifetime Member

Equipment
L4701, BH92, Frost Bite grapple, Logosol M8 mill, Stihl MS661
Aug 24, 2021
216
454
63
Rensselaer County NY
I agree: using the bucket for snow in my opinion is much like driving a nail with a crowbar. Works fine, but when you switch to a hammer/snowpusher it’s WAY better!

I prefer a snow pusher to the bucket because it’s easier and much faster to not have to constantly readjust the curl angle of the bucket to be just right so as to scoop up the snow without peeling up the gravel or grass. I have one on my L series, but also liked my first one I had on a B series.


With a bucket, at the end of your push you need to raise and dump the snow, and sometimes shake it out. The pusher is designed in such a way that when you stop pushing you can just back up and the snow will remain just like a plow would. With a little practice you can also pile snow using a pusher, just not quite as good as piling snow with a bucket but pretty close and better than a plow. My 84" pusher also has higher volume than my 84" bucket. I have used hydraulic angled plows and they work great, specially on larger tractors with the HP and traction they have, but the banks beside the driveway grew taller and the road narrowed as winter went by and that's why my first choice will always a blower to get that snow as far away as possible.

I can hammer a nail with a crow bar but it really isn't the right tool. I figure that there wouldn't be lots of manufacturers selling lots of snowpushers if they were no better than a bucket to begin with but that's JMHO.
 

Chadwiseman

New member

Equipment
Bx1880
Oct 5, 2024
3
1
3
Canada
I regret buying my pusher for 1880. If you’re going to push on dirt/gravel driveway, it will sink in the ground due to weight if your driveway isn’t frozen solid. I bought the land pride, which has thin shoes/skids. Bolted on from underneath. 48 inch width. If you get one, make sure the shoes are adjustable on the sides. I even tried putting washers in between the shoes and frame with no luck. Collects dust now. Trying to find a welder to widen the shoes. My rear 3 point blade is doing fine moving snow. My front blade just came in to this should be all I need. Good luck on you decision.
Thanks.. I have a fully paved driveway. I'm assuming the regret was with regard to having to use it on the gravel/dirt driveway?
 

Bearcatrp

Well-known member

Equipment
BX1880 with loader, mower and 3 point
Mar 28, 2023
645
343
63
Minnesota
Thanks.. I have a fully paved driveway. I'm assuming the regret was with regard to having to use it on the gravel/dirt driveway?
Yes. Have not a a solid brutal cold winter since getting it so my driveway hasn't frozen solid. Trying to have wider shoes made for it. For paved surface, this things are great though.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user

ajschnitzelbank

Well-known member
Lifetime Member

Equipment
L4701, BH92, Frost Bite grapple, Logosol M8 mill, Stihl MS661
Aug 24, 2021
216
454
63
Rensselaer County NY
Yes. Have not a a solid brutal cold winter since getting it so my driveway hasn't frozen solid. Trying to have wider shoes made for it. For paved surface, this things are great though.
Doesn’t everything suck when the gravel isn’t frozen? I mean, if the ground ia above freezing and the snow is like glue, my snowpusher can be kinda annoying. But so it the bucket, or an angled blade. Maybe snowblower is better I don’t know.
 

Moose7060

Well-known member

Equipment
M7060, L3902 HST, Farm King PT740, HLA 2500 Snowpusher, LandPride RCR1872
Oct 14, 2023
530
1,195
93
bc
Not sure how others do it, to each their own I guess, but I never rush clearing gravel driveways, etc until an inch or two of compact base has been built up. A nice solid base seems to make plowing, blowing, or pushing much better, and the chances of piling, throwing or digging the gravel much less. A paved drive is nice to get it down to the black, I find it certainly isn't necessary to see the gravel over winter. YMMV.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 users

Bearcatrp

Well-known member

Equipment
BX1880 with loader, mower and 3 point
Mar 28, 2023
645
343
63
Minnesota
I do let the first couple inches freeze and compacted. But need the temp to stay under 20 or less to keep it froze. Am hoping for a colder winter so I can actually try my pusher again.
 

Bearcatrp

Well-known member

Equipment
BX1880 with loader, mower and 3 point
Mar 28, 2023
645
343
63
Minnesota
Doesn’t everything suck when the gravel isn’t frozen? I mean, if the ground ia above freezing and the snow is like glue, my snowpusher can be kinda annoying. But so it the bucket, or an angled blade. Maybe snowblower is better I don’t know.
I turn my rear blade backwards, then adjust the pitch. Works fairly well. With the front blade on the loader, should be able to adjust the pitch to work as good as the rear blade. I used to use a walk behind snow blower on my driveway. Sucked watching gravel come out the shoot. After a few years doing that, came to the conclusion to get my 1880. No regrets!
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user

jimh406

Well-known member
Lifetime Member

Equipment
Kubota L2501 with R4 tires
Jan 29, 2021
2,360
1,794
113
Western MT
I think it depends on how long of a path you are clearing and how wide. If it's short path/driveway, it won't make much difference and if it's long and narrow, I'd prefer an angle blade.
 

Bearcatrp

Well-known member

Equipment
BX1880 with loader, mower and 3 point
Mar 28, 2023
645
343
63
Minnesota
I think it depends on how long of a path you are clearing and how wide. If it's short path/driveway, it won't make much difference and if it's long and narrow, I'd prefer an angle blade.
I always angle my rear blade to 45 degrees. Works well. Will do the same on my front one when snow hits the ground. I deal with long driveways.
 

Tim Horton

Active member
Mar 22, 2018
260
45
28
Lake Superior
Chad.... When I lived in northern BC, I had a used, very nice, 50" 3pt snowblower and a Piranha tooth bar on my bucket.. I used the tooth bar to keep ware off the bucket edge on our long gravel drive.. There will be a significant learning curve to using the tooth bar regardless of the surface you have, but this combo worked well.. I did all this with loaded turf tires and 2 link V bar ladder chains..

Again, this combo worked well on a compact tractor horse power and weight.. It took some time to do the job, but I didn't need ...one pass and done... kind of results..
The bucket teeth worked well for making grooves in packed snow and ice..
What part of the north are you in ??
Good luck..
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user

jyoutz

Well-known member

Equipment
MX6000 HST open station, FEL, 6’ cutter, forks, 8’ rear blade, 7’ cultivator
Jan 14, 2019
2,998
2,043
113
Edgewood, New Mexico
Doesn’t everything suck when the gravel isn’t frozen? I mean, if the ground ia above freezing and the snow is like glue, my snowpusher can be kinda annoying. But so it the bucket, or an angled blade. Maybe snowblower is better I don’t know.
I turn my rear blade around 180 degrees and then float it on the road bed and drive forward. It will skim over the road and move snow, but won’t move your gravel.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user

Bearcatrp

Well-known member

Equipment
BX1880 with loader, mower and 3 point
Mar 28, 2023
645
343
63
Minnesota
I turn my rear blade around 180 degrees and then float it on the road bed and drive forward. It will skim over the road and move snow, but won’t move your gravel.
Have been doing this last couple years. I adjust the pitch so the blade can contact the ground. Works great. Just received my front blade and plan on doing the same thing with it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user